- Tue Aug 20, 2019 12:49 pm
#118598
"Clown, you were too young to be involved in that era, so don't pretend you know about it."-johnfibs
Again, why is every word out of the mouths of conservatives nothing but made up stupid shit? johnny, you have no idea what you're talking about.
"The basic flaw in what you said was in assuming every young soldier can predict the outcome of a war, how political generals and politicians will manage it, and how historians will judge it."-johnfibs
Since my thesis doesn't rely in the slightest on any of those things, they can't possibly be a "basic flaw in what I said".
The war wasn't a crime against humanity because of who won or lost or what the outcome was. Even if the U.S. had 'won' it would STILL have been a crime against humanity.
"The goal in Vietnam was quite noble..."-johnfibs
No, it wasn't. It was nothing but politics-- part of a global chess game. It was an attempt to put in place malleable and compliant rulers to serve U.S. interests. ("to prevent communism from flowing southward." was just the propaganda for public consumption.) The proof of this is that we kept putting in leaders that the Vietnamese people didn't support. They got tossed out, then we propped up someone else that we liked to be hated by the Vietnamese.
"So blame the generals and the politicians, but not the soldiers who actually went there and tried."-johnfoibles
I don't even blame the generals. They were doing their jobs that most of them likely believed in. But they don't make policy. They wouldn't have been there at all if not ordered to be there. And I certainly wouldn't ever blame the soldiers, even if they supported the war. But what Johnson did, even after he knew the War was unwinnable and pointless, is unforgivable. And McNamara should have quit his job and told the American people what was really going on. It could have saved thousands of lives and years of social upheaval here at home which is still not healed.